Wed 18 Nov

BAH! HUMBUG! A Christmas Carol review by Keith Richardson

KEITH RICHARDSON casts off his cloak of generosity and gets all mean and miserly with Ebenezer Scrooge and a host of shining lights at Theatre by the Lake’s production of ‘A Christmas Carol.’ (Until January 3, 2027).

CHRISTMAS comes early to Keswick; the seasonal lights and decorations are up and dazzling long before All Hallows’ Eve or Guy Fawkes (who he?) have fizzled out. It is only a matter of time, methinks, before Christmas starts and ends in July, not unlike the never-ending soccer season which begins all over again before the final whistle has been blown on the last.

But before I start rambling on about eternal damnation and other minor irritations, let’s revisit another annual tradition of Christmas in Keswick: the festive show at Theatre by the Lake.

And, unlike Christmas, I am glad it’s here because “A Christmas Carol” is a joy. 

On leaving the theatre after the show I was asked by a TBTL marketing person who shall remain nameless (it was Rachel Kearns) what I thought of the production. Not only that, I was asked to do so in just three words.

“Joyful, jolly and accomplished,” I said off the top of my head before heading off into the rain and cold of a bleak house Derwentwater night. On reflection and given a little more time I might have said “Feel good factor.” Three words I had scribbled as an aide-memoire on my show programme.

And that was clearly a sentiment shared by a sell-out audience who applauded, roared, hollered, shouted, and whistled their appreciation of the production come the ‘final curtain.’ And at other points in between.

What was there not to love about this show, adapted from the book by Charles Dickens (naturally), written by Matt Borgatti, music and lyrics by Will Dollard and Mary Erskine and directed by Andy Barry. This was a Theatre by the Lake production in association with Goblin.

This was also A Christmas Carol with a difference, fresh, energetic and (yes, I return to that word again) fun. It also had its moments of shock-horror, enhanced by the cat’s death, chalk on blackboard screech of a violin or cello, and a statue that grinds into life. Or was it death?

Anyways, it was the perfect antidote to that world-weary, end-of-autumn-beginning-of winter-days-and-nights nightmare when, quite frankly, you quietly despair, question your whereabouts, the meaning of life and perchance start to dream of faraway Caribbean shores. And warm, oh so warm sunshine and azure waters. And pina coladas.

The entire cast of Miiya Alexandra, Matthew Burns, Zach Burns, Neal Craig, Connor Going, Leah Jamieson and Eleanor Toms were all superb. With special mention for Matthew Burns and Neal Craig for their more prominent roles as choirmaster / onstage MD and Ebenezer Scrooge, respectively.

The music and dance was tremendous, the set (a candlelit Gothic church) and sound and lighting effects awesome and I also loved it when a troubled Scrooge went on walkabout (complete with lantern) into the audience to come to terms with a mind troubled by the arrival of ghosts, past, present and future. The introduction of puppets to play the parts of Tiny Tim and a young Belle was also effective, ala ‘War Horse’ without the hooves.

Dickens’ story has the bonus of an eternal message, be kind; a man (or woman) and not a ghost. ‘Be you cruel or kind, think of what you leave behind.’

A Christmas Carol concludes what has been a triumphant 2026 for TBTL.

Every play I have seen and reviewed for this website, starting with ‘Lark Rise to Candleford’ way back in March has been exceptional. And as a parting shot to 2026, as I finally left the theatre on Tuesday night (November 17, no less) someone made the mistake of wishing me a merry Christmas. There was, of course, only one appropriate reply to that. Which was where we came in.

BAH! HUMBUG!

SANTA NOTES:

A Christmas Carol is being staged at Theatre by the Lake until Sunday, January 3.

And from Tuesday, December 8 to Sunday, December 27, TBTL is also staging A Town Called Christmas, a series of shows designed especially for children aged 3+ and their grown-ups. More information elsewhere on this website.

Keith Richardson is an author and journalist who masquerades as a volunteer groundsman at Keswick Cricket Club in the summer months.